Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
+2
RayvenNightkind
MannyJabrielle
6 posters
Page 1 of 1
Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
The soulgathering sword used to be really great. Good DC on slaying undead, good look, not something you can just walk up to a merchant and buy.
However, since it now doesnt allow mages to cast GMW on it, nor any other weapon enhancing magic, it's really a pretty crappy sword. The mace of disruption is far better all around. This just doesn't seem right since the SG sword requires some decent skillpoints to find, requires 21+ levels to use, and just seems like it's supposed to be a sword that doesn't suck. As it stands, the mace of disruption which can easily be purchased from a merchant offers a +3 EB, as well as a slay undead on hit property.... and is a far better weapon for the 21+ crowd.
The main problem with it is that it has two properties. Enhancement bonus +1, and the slay undead on hit property. With only +1, this sword is nice for popping skeletons, but at level 21+, the average PC is gonna be able to smack around skeletons anyway, and probably even better with any other given weapon, which can be buffed up with the various weapon spells.
Now, if this sword's purpose is supposed to be sending the undead packing for the greathall, and not a multi-purpose weapon, it would be better to swap out the +1 enhancement bonus with a better one vs undead (+5 vs undead perhaps).
Vs undead, the sword will be useful. Against anything else, no so much as the enhancement would only work vs undead. As it stands now though, with the sword NOT being able to take a cast of GMW or anything else, it's a rather large letdown as a great artifact of aenea.
However, since it now doesnt allow mages to cast GMW on it, nor any other weapon enhancing magic, it's really a pretty crappy sword. The mace of disruption is far better all around. This just doesn't seem right since the SG sword requires some decent skillpoints to find, requires 21+ levels to use, and just seems like it's supposed to be a sword that doesn't suck. As it stands, the mace of disruption which can easily be purchased from a merchant offers a +3 EB, as well as a slay undead on hit property.... and is a far better weapon for the 21+ crowd.
The main problem with it is that it has two properties. Enhancement bonus +1, and the slay undead on hit property. With only +1, this sword is nice for popping skeletons, but at level 21+, the average PC is gonna be able to smack around skeletons anyway, and probably even better with any other given weapon, which can be buffed up with the various weapon spells.
Now, if this sword's purpose is supposed to be sending the undead packing for the greathall, and not a multi-purpose weapon, it would be better to swap out the +1 enhancement bonus with a better one vs undead (+5 vs undead perhaps).
Vs undead, the sword will be useful. Against anything else, no so much as the enhancement would only work vs undead. As it stands now though, with the sword NOT being able to take a cast of GMW or anything else, it's a rather large letdown as a great artifact of aenea.
MannyJabrielle- Ludicrous Level
- . :
Number of posts : 5927
Main Character : See the "A-Team" thread in the Biographies forum.
DM Name : Dungeon-Master Gaelen
Time Zone : GMT -5:00(EST)
Registration date : 2008-07-05
Re: Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
I agree with Manny on this one, it does seem that the searching that goes into getting it that it would have a bit more bite to it. But that's just not the case, would really love to see this one beefed up a lil bit.
RayvenNightkind- Epic Level
- Number of posts : 1119
Age : 49
Location : Park View (Eldridge), Iowa
Main Character : Sir Rayvensclaw Nightkind Leader of the Clan of Night
Paladin/Champion of Dalix/Wizard
NWN Username : Rayven Nightkind
Time Zone : GMT - 6:00
Registration date : 2008-09-04
Re: Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
i do as well..i used to use this for sykee while carving up mummies...i would gmw....pop the elemental stuff on it.....and go to town. I used it to simulate his mindblade.
However now that i cant buff or even enchant it....its just a toy...i stuff it in my back and break out my spear of doom...i lose the shield..but a +10 spear with a boatload of stuff on it is just better.
Maybe the soulsword could be made like that spear and or that staff we all know about
However now that i cant buff or even enchant it....its just a toy...i stuff it in my back and break out my spear of doom...i lose the shield..but a +10 spear with a boatload of stuff on it is just better.
Maybe the soulsword could be made like that spear and or that staff we all know about
Re: Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
I think manny has the right idea here. That sword does smack of being an undead killer. A useful enhancement bonus vs. undead makes the most sense, and +5 seems apprpriate because of the process involved in obtaining it.
Any reason as to how or why the sword does not accept spells? Is it the CEP issue? or something different?
Any reason as to how or why the sword does not accept spells? Is it the CEP issue? or something different?
daveyeisley- Ludicrous Level
- . :
Number of posts : 6934
Age : 47
Location : Watching Aenea from my Inner Sanctum on the surface of Sharlo, Aenea's Silver Moon
Main Character : Dave's List of PCs
NWN Username : Dave Yeisley
DM Name : Dungeon Master Mythgar
Time Zone : GMT - 5:00
. :
Registration date : 2008-06-03
Re: Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
Im not certain....when i used it on sykee it took my first round of spells fine...went to +5..hadall the buffs...then...all of a sudden when the spells were spose to run out.....they stuck. They didnt fade like they was spose to...then..when i rebuffed it..it still said +5 but i kept gettin the *Weapon ineffective* popup thing.
I myself have been puzzling it around in my head a bit...and i think it might...might be the fact that model has no model at all. Its just a emmiter effect. I know if you try to make a bladeless sword...just a hilt and handle...the game either puts a lovely bag....or....just locks up when you try to load in with it. Im wondering if thats the issue. Ill try it on iggy's flame sword and see if i get the same result.
Now manny said it wont take buffs anymore...i wonder if ad locked it out to prevent the problems i mentioned from cropping up. its a cool idea...but it needs to be +5 then or something cause like manny said...mummies need +3 i believe to hit them...and other undead need even +2...at +1 it makes the sword more of a novelty then a useful item vs. the amount of effort in obtaining it.
I myself have been puzzling it around in my head a bit...and i think it might...might be the fact that model has no model at all. Its just a emmiter effect. I know if you try to make a bladeless sword...just a hilt and handle...the game either puts a lovely bag....or....just locks up when you try to load in with it. Im wondering if thats the issue. Ill try it on iggy's flame sword and see if i get the same result.
Now manny said it wont take buffs anymore...i wonder if ad locked it out to prevent the problems i mentioned from cropping up. its a cool idea...but it needs to be +5 then or something cause like manny said...mummies need +3 i believe to hit them...and other undead need even +2...at +1 it makes the sword more of a novelty then a useful item vs. the amount of effort in obtaining it.
Re: Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
locked out the spell buffing I do believe, as the sword was meant to be a collection of souls bound together to bring undead into the greathall where they're supposed to be (or something along those lines), rather than an all purpose kill stuff weapon.
As for the game locking up because of a null middle-bottom part, that sounds more like an issue with the install than the game itself. I've never had that particular blade model (or any other emitter and/or null part) lockup the game, and would only get bags if there was an error in the hackpack containing the model being used.
As for the game locking up because of a null middle-bottom part, that sounds more like an issue with the install than the game itself. I've never had that particular blade model (or any other emitter and/or null part) lockup the game, and would only get bags if there was an error in the hackpack containing the model being used.
MannyJabrielle- Ludicrous Level
- . :
Number of posts : 5927
Main Character : See the "A-Team" thread in the Biographies forum.
DM Name : Dungeon-Master Gaelen
Time Zone : GMT -5:00(EST)
Registration date : 2008-07-05
Re: Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
MannyJabrielle wrote: locked out the spell buffing I do believe, as the sword was meant to be a collection of souls bound together to bring undead into the greathall where they're supposed to be (or something along those lines), rather than an all purpose kill stuff weapon.
If I understood correctly when I asked him about it a while back, Manny hit it right on the head. made it so it couldn't be buffed by magic or any other means. As it is a blade made of souls there is no way to "buff" it.
RayvenNightkind- Epic Level
- Number of posts : 1119
Age : 49
Location : Park View (Eldridge), Iowa
Main Character : Sir Rayvensclaw Nightkind Leader of the Clan of Night
Paladin/Champion of Dalix/Wizard
NWN Username : Rayven Nightkind
Time Zone : GMT - 6:00
Registration date : 2008-09-04
Re: Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
I did change it so that it no longer accepts standard enchantments. I did go with a suggestion that was somewhere in this thread and make it +5 enhancement vs. undead, plus I put in a little extra positive energy damage vs. undead.
If you have the sword already talk to a DM and get the new version swapped for your older one. You can tell them it's under Items > Custom > Plot
If you have the sword already talk to a DM and get the new version swapped for your older one. You can tell them it's under Items > Custom > Plot
RayvenNightkind- Epic Level
- Number of posts : 1119
Age : 49
Location : Park View (Eldridge), Iowa
Main Character : Sir Rayvensclaw Nightkind Leader of the Clan of Night
Paladin/Champion of Dalix/Wizard
NWN Username : Rayven Nightkind
Time Zone : GMT - 6:00
Registration date : 2008-09-04
Re: Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
Off topic, is "less pants" a British saying? I assume it means to suck less, or be undesirable?
Aeroldoth- Adventurer
- Number of posts : 33
Registration date : 2009-03-14
Re: Partially Used: Soul Gathering Sword - A suggestion to make it less pants
Hrmm, don't think it's strictly British. I'm not British. And yes, pants = sucks
MannyJabrielle- Ludicrous Level
- . :
Number of posts : 5927
Main Character : See the "A-Team" thread in the Biographies forum.
DM Name : Dungeon-Master Gaelen
Time Zone : GMT -5:00(EST)
Registration date : 2008-07-05
Similar topics
» Partially Used: Hat of Disguise Suggestion
» Partially Used: Another Info Time suggestion
» Partially Used: Suggestion: Buying in bulk
» Partially Used: item suggestion -- angel feathers
» Partially Used: Suggestion/Update Quaking Chorus?
» Partially Used: Another Info Time suggestion
» Partially Used: Suggestion: Buying in bulk
» Partially Used: item suggestion -- angel feathers
» Partially Used: Suggestion/Update Quaking Chorus?
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum